Trump Bans Transgenders from the Military

[Crash187]

Let's just fix this shit right here. You were born with a dick? I don't give a shit what you think you are, you're a guy. Born with a pussy? I don't give a shit what you think you are, you're a woman. No amount of hormones, surgery, or anything else will change that. Remember those XY and XX chromosomes we all learned about around the age of 13-15? Yeah that's proven science (something all the hey we need to hug everybody say they support). So tell me how again this isn't a mental illness?

[time4fun]

Let's just fix this shit right here. You were born with a dick? I don't give a shit what you think you are, you're a guy. Born with a pussy? I don't give a shit what you think you are, you're a woman. No amount of hormones, surgery, or anything else will change that. Remember those XY and XX chromosomes we all learned about around the age of 13-15? Yeah that's proven science (something all the hey we need to hug everybody say they support). So tell me how again this isn't a mental illness?

There are five chromosomal variations of X and Y in humans not two. (Technically more, but I don't want your head to explode)

And human societies have had between 2-5 genders, as documented by anthropologists.

I guess your 13 year old understanding of gender and sex in humans isn't accurate.

Shocking.

[Crash187]

There are five chromosomal variations of X and Y in humans not two.

I guess your 13 year old understanding of gender and sex in humans isn't accurate.

Shocking.

Ok, take out the chromosomes. You have a pussy? You're a female. You have a dick? You're a male. You have both? decide what you want to be and stick with it. Anything other than 3 options is a mental illness

[Methais]

And human societies have had between 2-5 genders, as documented by anthropologists

Nobody is making the claim that mental illness is something new.

I bet you think the Earth is flat too.

[Wrathbringer]

Let's just fix this shit right here. You were born with a dick? I don't give a shit what you think you are, you're a guy. Born with a pussy? I don't give a shit what you think you are, you're a woman. No amount of hormones, surgery, or anything else will change that. Remember those XY and XX chromosomes we all learned about around the age of 13-15? Yeah that's proven science (something all the hey we need to hug everybody say they support). So tell me how again this isn't a mental illness?

This is correct.

[Wrathbringer]

There are five chromosomal variations of X and Y in humans not two. (Technically more, but I don't want your head to explode)

And human societies have had between 2-5 genders, as documented by anthropologists.

I guess your 13 year old understanding of gender and sex in humans isn't accurate.

Shocking.

This is retarded.

[Crash187]

This is retarded.

I was attempting to be nice and not go all hateful.

[Crash187]

There are five chromosomal variations of X and Y in humans not two. (Technically more, but I don't want your head to explode)

And human societies have had between 2-5 genders, as documented by anthropologists.

I guess your 13 year old understanding of gender and sex in humans isn't accurate.

Shocking.

No actually there's not. There's XXYY, Xyy, etc and imagine that, they all have physical or mental disabilities. Keep preaching though.

[Stumplicker]

There are five chromosomal variations of X and Y in humans not two. (Technically more, but I don't want your head to explode)

And human societies have had between 2-5 genders, as documented by anthropologists.

I guess your 13 year old understanding of gender and sex in humans isn't accurate.

Shocking.

I understand what you're referencing anthropologically, but I want to say - Don't drag anthropology into this or I'm going to come into this particular argument against you. You know I'm generally on the trans rights side of things on issues, as I am on the original point of the thread, but you're muddling anthropological musings on social construction with a dimorphic biological system to try to make a point, and i'm not okay with that.

[BigWorm]

Sincere question: what is the criticism of Kristen Beck based on? Afaik she was decorated SEAL who earned a bronze star and purple heart during her 20 years of service. Seems like someone who would be very difficult to replace. I honestly don't understand how banning her improves our military.