Quote Originally Posted by Tgo01 View Post
Do you even know what a "false dilemma" fallacy is?

It's where someone sets up a question as if there is only two choices but there might be more choices. I literally just asked what you think about a government forcibly taking land from a minority population. That is simply asking for your input, I am not only giving you two possible answers. I'm glad you know the names of some fallacies, but at least try to use them properly next time. Thanks.
Your question has only a black/white answer but it's a highly complicated issue and you also haven't referenced S. African history or present day circumstances. The wording of your question also has loaded implications. You use words like "forcibly" and "minority". No matter how you protest, yours is not an honest question.


My question to you is honest and it's open ended enough for you to clarify your answers. It's not a trap and there's no "gotcha".

What are you ideas to solve the land ownership problem in S. Africa? Have you any?