I've found my way into a few nifty two-handers. Situationally they all have merits, just looking for an opinion on effectiveness. Numbers below. Ignoring the blessable aspect, and figuring I can aim them all reasonably well in the open (with the claid being 1 second slower), what are the overall impressions? I want to like the claid the most, change my mind?

+22 new style claid with dispel flares:
According to Whirlin's sheet: Avg raw blood loss - 49, Total blood loss per swing, 83.96, total chance of crit kill 27.28%

+50 perfect maul, T5, 6 cer crit, KO flares:
According to Whirlin's sheet: Avg raw blood loss - 70, Total blood loss per swing, 99.81, total chance of crit kill 19.63%

+35 perfect mattock, T5, 4 cer crit, KO flares:
According to Whirlin's sheet: Avg raw blood loss - 64, Total blood loss per swing, 89.94, total chance of crit kill 15.41%

Used ASG 14 just for comparison, higher ASG favors the maul, of course. AvD against plate with the T5 is giving me rolls 20-45 higher with the maul/mattock, which is what is holding me up the most.