Originally Posted by
Sighisoara
I disagree with that assessment because kidnapping has nothing to do with the wishes or rights of a parent (not just kids can be kidnapped after all) whereas the other offense does, that’s the primary difference - without authority. Otherwise, every cop that arrests someone would be guilty of kidnapping.
I agree with your assessment about the shitty scenario, that jurisdiction is clear.
The wishes of the parent ARE the authority though, for a minor. As an adult, the authority would obviously derive from the person themself.
And no, unlawful arrest is false imprisonment.
So many hairs to split.
Last edited by Gelston; 05-12-2022 at 05:10 PM.
Ceterum censeo Carthaginem esse delendam