Originally Posted by
Menos
My experience is fairly limited, but I am a fan of spears for throwing. Lots of puncture, relatively good DFs, very fast speed. They do have some downsides; the training threshold is higher (poles/thrown/brawl), they are in pretty darn limited supply and seem to be expensive.
Chain spears are fairly attainable but have the extra retract roundtime and can only be thrown in the one handed form.
Spear bando's are also out there, as you mentioned above.
I'm not sure on the total number of returning/stringed spears, but I get the feeling it is fairly small.
There may have been one or two made, with a revised script. The reason they aren't normally allowed with the returner script is because this:
With a quick flick of your wrist, you deftly send a black glaes throwing axe into flight.
You throw a black glaes throwing axe at a darkly inked fetish master!
AS: +685 vs DS: +491 with AvD: +30 + d100 roll: +94 = +318
... and hit for 117 points of damage!
Hard blow to the fetish master's ear!
Deep gash and a terrible headache!
The fetish master is stunned!
Your glaes throwing axe
spins rapidly through the air, the blade whooshing audibly with each revolution. As it completes its arc, it reverses direction and lands solidly in your right hand, ready to throw again.
Roundtime: 4 sec
The whole thing makes zero sense for a spear. Now, in true Gemstone fashion, you can come up with a way and a logic no matter how contorted, to make anything make "sense." There was a GM who was going to add the script and said it would work with spears, but then took a look at it and changed their minds. I wouldn't be surprised if someone went ahead and did it and changed the wording some way, or just didn't realize what they were doing and went with it with the normal wording.
The chain spears are super cool but are not as mechanically effective as a regular returner.
As for enchanting, the only thing to be concerned about was always the risk. No matter how small the risk, the things are just worth too much to lose if there is some risk there. I have probably done about a dozen returner enchants with PPs, but I don't think I've ever had a mage do one. With the changes to mage enchanting maybe that's a safer bet, but I was never comfortable enough with it to risk something worth a small fortune.
I don't use Lich. If you want to do business with me, contact me via PM, IG, or on AIM. Or maybe use smoke signals. Don't like it, get off of my lawn.