Merchant Feedback

http://i0.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/...28/498/2d5.gif

Did a GOA with Roblar for his silvers and transaction was very smooth and prompt

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Berubeo21

You still have brought no proof of my shadiness besides your own particular opinion as well as "a few folks", so take your fake news elsewhere. Think of instant replay in football ect; you go back and look at what happened and you make the right call, in this case the right call is the person who messaged me first. I messaged you saying that i'm sorry but that I had missed a previous message in a conversation that I was having with another party. My auction, my items, my rules. Shady would have been for me to ghost you or make up some kind of lie, telling the truth is not being shady.
Here is a link to the good feedback that i've had over the years, then there is you...
http://forum.gsplayers.com/search.php?searchid=4550650

---

Doesn't seem like an opinion or fake news when you pretty much acknowledged that you screwed them over. It also doesn't help your case anymore when you act like a child about your bad mechanting practices.

It sounds like the guy made a buyout offer, which was accepted, then got impatient and reduced his offer because he didn't want to wait... Making it no longer valid?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SashaFierce

It sounds like the guy made a buyout offer, which was accepted, then got impatient and reduced his offer because he didn't want to wait... Making it no longer valid?

---

reading comprehension please, it is very clear that is not what happened.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by SashaFierce

It sounds like the guy made a buyout offer, which was accepted, then got impatient and reduced his offer because he didn't want to wait... Making it no longer valid?

---

From both buyer and seller it states that they both agreed to the buyout. The seller asked if they could deliver the next day and the buyer was fine with that. The seller stated they even updated the thread to sold after they both agreed on the buyout. During the time it took for the seller to deliver they received a higher offer and then took that and pulled out of the originally buyout they already accepted the previous day. That's the summary for the post that matter out of both stories from both parties. Everything else is irrelevant since they didn't commit up until the last dealings.

Quick, easy sale with Berubeo21, would do business again =)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chaumel

I'm not gonna put their names out there since it first off isn't relevant to the facts of what transpired, and also would be rude of me to drag them into this like that. A few folks I've talked to about the situation have made comments though that you (Spert) are shady and they aren't surprised you would do something so crumby. Given not just your messages here, but your need to issue further insults to my rep comments (Which didn't move me rep at all, showing what your rep is worth) you just show yourself to be less reliable.

So for those who want to know. This is in regards to his auction in high value items, specifically, the logic daggers. When the thread first went up, I offered a BO on the daggers and the cloak as a combo deal. I misunderstood what the cloak was (Confused it with a different DR cloak) and immediately asked a question to confirm my misunderstanding, and to withdraw my interest in the cloak (before he had replied to me), but wanted to put in an offer on the daggers. Over 24 hours later, he replied to my original offer on the cloak and wasn't interested in the first offer which included it, he then replied to the second message where I asked a question on the cloak, and also had my separate offer for the daggers, and didn't comment on my offer on the daggers. I continued to watch the thread over the next day, and the daggers were getting very little action, and were at a price well below my initial BO offer.

I then messaged him again about my offer to BO the daggers, but since he had ignored my original offer without comment, and the daggers had received no bids in over a day, I reduced my offer. I stated that I was not interested in auctions, that I didn't want that message to be ignored for over a day, like my previous ones, or to be shopped around, and thus gave him a deadline of Sunday afternoon to reply, else I'd consider the offer rejected. Early Sunday afternoon, he sent me a message accepting my reduced BO. When i saw it and replied a couple hours later to set up delivery, he responded several hours later saying he couldn't today, but would do so on Monday due to RL issues. I said no big deal, and to message me when he was available Monday.

Monday morning I get on and have a message saying he had another offer that was higher, and he was going with it, and cancelling our deal and saying he had accepted the other offer. I acknowledged his reply with a simple "Right." and then made my post here. I then told several friends about it, in the details as above, and those who knew Spart said he was shady and they were not surprised, but agreed that what had happened was a definite breech of merchant etiquette.

While it still would have been very shady no doubt, if he had come to me and asked if I would raise my offer to match what he told me the final offer was, I very likely would have due to my interest in the item. He had already said he had accepted the other offer though, and I didn't want to put someone else in a crappy spot by having him renege on them as well. I do feel it is important though to make people aware of this behavior so they can make informed decisions when buying from him in the future. When he had asked to delay delivery, it did raise those little hairs at the back of my neck, and thankfully because of that I did not go out and make a deal to buy the orb I would need to finish the daggers, because if something happened I wouldn't want to treat them this way, since the orb would no longer be as useful to me.

Now to await my next neg rep from him, calling me some other name, seems to be a pattern.

---

Not saying there wasn't some BS involved here, but if you PM'd me bitching me out for missing a prior PM then giving me a deadline for your BO to expire and accused me of shopping around for the best offer, I'd have refused to sell them to you outright.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jhynnifer

Not saying there wasn't some BS involved here, but if you PM'd me bitching me out for missing a prior PM then giving me a deadline for your BO to expire and accused me of shopping around for the best offer, I'd have refused to sell them to you outright.

---

That would of been ok and it's your right as a seller to do that. But the seller didn't do that. He accepted And agreed on a delivery the next day for the buyout. So that other info seems irrelevant unless the seller refused to sell or accept a buyout and said buyer came on here to complain about that situation. But it's not that situation. The buyer just presented all that info but the seller came on here with childish responses to justify his dishonorable merchanting (in this particular transaction) to make matters worse in their case.

Essentially people can do what they want and make their own decisions. But there is a feedback thread here for a reason. If you handle situations like this people are either going to post here or not. The thread is here for a reason. We have a very small community here so it would be best to be civil with each other. It's ultimately better for everyone at the end of the day.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Jhynnifer

Not saying there wasn't some BS involved here, but if you PM'd me bitching me out for missing a prior PM then giving me a deadline for your BO to expire and accused me of shopping around for the best offer, I'd have refused to sell them to you outright.

---

That was my concern as well, but the seller had ample opportunity to bring up that point as reason for breaking off the deal. They did not. I trust everyone at their word that the deal was broken because the seller found a higher offer after accepting the original one, and more specifically "my auction my rules".