PDA

View Full Version : Online buyers less likely to buy from tattooed or black sellers



Drew
12-16-2013, 06:32 PM
http://assets.nydailynews.com/polopoly_fs/1.1549595.1387228791!/img/httpImage/image.jpg_gen/derivatives/landscape_635/shop17n-2-web.jpg
Online shoppers are less likely to buy something from a person who’s black or has tattoos, a new study suggests.
Researchers sent out 1,200 online classified ads for Apple iPods and were shocked at the discrimination they found. Ads featuring a black or tattooed hand holding the iPod received 18% fewer offers — and bids that did come through were lower than those offered to white sellers without visible tattoos, according to the report published in the Economic Journal of the Royal Economic Society.
“We might have moved many of our consumer transactions online, but personal biases in terms of who we trust still affect how we interact with others,” study co-author Jennifer Doleac, a public policy and economics professor at the University of Virginia, told the Daily News.

“This is true when we’re interacting online as well as offline.”
The ads researchers placed were all for an 8GB silver iPod nano, and included an explanation that it was for sale because the seller didn’t need it. In a photo, it was held by a man’s hand that was white, black or white with a wrist tattoo.
People were more likely to respond to an ad, go through with the purchase, and be more comfortable making a long-distance payment when the seller was white and didn’t have any visible tattoos, researchers wrote.

They were most wary when talking to black sellers.
“For instance, they are less likely to include their names in their emails,” Doleac said.
Researchers did note that black sellers got more responses in areas with larger black populations and fewer responses from buyers who lived in high-crime areas. They weren’t aware of the buyers’ race.
Doleac was most surprised that white tattooed sellers got similar results to black sellers. This means buyers are “statistically discriminating,” rather than discriminating solely based on race.
“The buyer is trying to avoid dealing with someone who is less educated, for instance, or who might live in a bad neighborhood,” she explained.


http://www.nydailynews.com/life-style/sellers-race-matters-e-commerce-article-1.1549596

Taernath
12-16-2013, 06:34 PM
I wouldn't buy from someone with a Kanji tattoo either.

Tgo01
12-16-2013, 06:35 PM
I wouldn't buy from someone with a Kanji tattoo either.

^

Also how come they didn't include women in this study?

Taernath
12-16-2013, 06:39 PM
Maybe it's more like those who grip their iPods from the side have an 18% less chance to sell them compared to those who do the top and bottom... Sort of a subconscious 'pry it from my cold dead hands' thing. I think we've found a flaw in their methodology.

Drew
12-16-2013, 06:41 PM
Maybe it's more like those who grip their iPods from the side have an 18% less chance to sell them compared to those who do the top and bottom... Sort of a subconscious 'pry it from my cold dead hands' thing. I think we've found a flaw in their methodology.

It's funny cause I thought of that exact same thing.

Tgo01
12-16-2013, 06:52 PM
Plus you can see the tattooed guy in the reflection on the ipod, he looks like an angry skinhead! I wouldn't buy from him either.

The white non tattoo guy also has the best picture as well, he's using flash and everything. Plus the wall in the background is a nice smooth color whereas the tattoo guy has like a yellowish wall and the black guy has a rough looking wall.

Shouldn't they have accounted for all of these variables? Like had everyone hold the item the exact same way against the exact same background and made sure no one was visible in the ipod?

Man someone should set me up with a cozy job at a university, I can half ass studies with the best of them!

Latrinsorm
12-16-2013, 07:01 PM
Maybe it's more like those who grip their iPods from the side have an 18% less chance to sell them compared to those who do the top and bottom... Sort of a subconscious 'pry it from my cold dead hands' thing. I think we've found a flaw in their methodology.I know you're not super serious, but I am super serious about this. They didn't even control how the iPodPad looked on the screen: the top left's screen looks greenish-gray and therefore Game Boy, the bottom left's screen looks jet black and therefore Game Boy Pocket. This is an enormous difference.

Frankly, I wouldn't expect anything better from researchers with a superfluous X chromosome.

Ker_Thwap
12-17-2013, 11:48 AM
Craigslist, Ebay, Amazon? Any other way of determining seller reliability? White person in bad neighborhood vs black person in good neighborhood? Race and neighborhood of the buyer? I want a real study with real statistical modeling.

Wrathbringer
12-26-2013, 09:24 AM
http://www.nydailynews.com/life-style/sellers-race-matters-e-commerce-article-1.1549596

Well duh, no one wants to get scammed. When I ebay search, I filter out items listed by the blacks, the chinese, women of any race, items from trailer parks, liberal states and any seller with 420 in their username. It's the safest way to buy.