PDA

View Full Version : Judge- Players can seek future NCAA revenue



Gelston
11-09-2013, 12:32 PM
A federal judge on Friday partially certified a lawsuit filed by more than 20 players, allowing football and basketball players in major programs to challenge as a group NCAA rules prohibiting compensation beyond the value of their athletic scholarships, but also denying their pursuit of billions of dollars in past revenues.

In her long-awaited, 24-page report, U.S. District Judge Claudia Wilken carved a pathway for fundamental change in the economic model of college sports in a ruling that will help college athletes in their arguments to receive a share of television and other media revenues.

The ruling also minimized the prospect of forcing the NCAA to pay billions of dollars in past damages to players who may have been wronged under anti-trust law. Players can still sue for damages, but only as individuals.

The mixed ruling left both sides claiming victory in statements sent to ESPN.

"The court's decision is a victory for all current and former student-athletes who are seeking compensation on a going forward basis," said Michael Hausfeld, lead attorney for the players. "While we are disappointed that the court did not permit the athletes to seek past damages as a group, we are nevertheless hopeful that the court's decision will cause the NCAA to reconsider its business practices."

The NCAA addressed only the side of the judge's decision it favors. The governing body for college sports had been accused by the plaintiffs of working with member institutions to fix at the price of zero the amount of Division I basketball players and Football Bowl Subdivision players could receive as players.

http://espn.go.com/espn/otl/story/_/id/9949204/players-seek-future-revenue-ncaa-pursue-damages

---

About time I think. The kids can't work and earn money to the same degree as other college students (in fact, they aren't allowed to work over so many hours a week).

Methais
11-09-2013, 12:50 PM
I always thought it was stupid that the players made nothing while the schools made millions, but at the same time, they'll probably use this as an excuse to raise tuition on everyone now.

senorgordoburro
11-09-2013, 12:50 PM
This is huge, lots of doors just got opened though and it will take a while for some hard rules to get established I bet.

cwolff
11-09-2013, 12:58 PM
This is huge, lots of doors just got opened though and it will take a while for some hard rules to get established I bet.

It is huge. I'm ambivalent on this subject. The players get some great benefits just for their athletic ability but they also generate shit tons of money while not being able to take advantage of it.

Ideally I'd like to see more opportunity for players outside of the NCAA. I often hear/make jokes about dumb jocks who didn't finish school but when you consider (especially in football) that one of the only options they have to pursue their career is within the NCAA system, I begin to wonder if it's fair criticism.

Latrinsorm
11-09-2013, 02:52 PM
Until we can quantify (especially for football) the consequences of playing sports, there is no way to conclude whether the players are fairly compensated with a scholarship. Consequently, there is no way for anyone (let alone some 18 year old kid) to make an informed decision about playing sports for a scholarship.

Why don't we just stick to services rendered? 50/50 split: the owners get 50%, the workers get 50%.
I always thought it was stupid that the players made nothing while the schools made millions, but at the same time, they'll probably use this as an excuse to raise tuition on everyone now.That's true, business owners have ever been interested in only profits. If only there were some governing force we could bring to bear to regulate their naked greed in the interests of Justice, domestic Tranquility, the common Welfare...

waywardgs
11-09-2013, 03:43 PM
Methais is a socialist?!

Methais
11-09-2013, 04:02 PM
Methais is a socialist?!

No. The players are actually doing work.

waywardgs
11-09-2013, 04:15 PM
No. The players are actually doing work.

Oh, you're a communist!

Latrinsorm
11-09-2013, 04:18 PM
No. The players are actually doing work.Anyone who gets out of bed in the morning does work... against gravity!

This joke brought to you by the physics you never bothered to pay attention to.