claidhmore vs. other THW

[LOL BRIELUS]

At what point does the claidhmore become not as efficient as another THW?

For example...I have a 5x mattock, whats better, the claid with its weighting, or my mattock, with more enchant and better AvD/DF?

[Durgrimst]

IMO weighting is more important with if you have a low AS, some race/class combos can pull off endrolls that will almost guarantee a high rank crit nearly every try if they have a nice enchant and no weighting, but others cannot and need weighting to make up for it.

[WRoss]

claid weighted mattock = problem solved

[James469]

What about 4x katana vs invar claid? I have a half krol warrior; is the RT reduction and +18 AS worth the crit weighting loss?

[Danical]

No; katanas fucking suck.

[Drew]

Only use a katana if it give you a chub to have one. There's really no reason otherwise mechanically.

[Drew]

claid weighted mattock = problem solved

And this.